A while back I went to a Filipino event at a large Toronto venue. It was an outdoor event and unfortunately it was raining, though luckily the venue had large open air tents to keep the people dry—but for some reason I smelled wet dog.
I was reminded of my youth when I was ashamed of being Filipino.
I was ashamed of the so-called culture that I saw: The worship of a European Jesus irritated me. The accented attempts to sing Western songs made me run—in case friends happen to see me there. So-called ‘traditional’ clothes shamed me as I saw only variations on a European theme. Worship of all things American sickened me.
Was this what it meant to be Filipino? It seemed to me only an imitation of a Spanish or American original. So I became ‘Canadian,’ at least then I didn’t have to imitate, I could be one of the creators.
But that could only last for so long.
I, like most youth, was searching for identity. Sure most just picked one and was done with it, but for some reason I really wanted to discover who and what I was. And being honest in this search, I eventually came to realize that I wasn’t ‘Canadian.’
I remember during my years in Asia I was often told by White travellers, after they finished complaining about some local cultural more that I tried to comprehend, that I should stop defending them. They smiled and said that to them I seemed more Western than Asian. I think they meant it as a complement.
Every time I heard that, and I heard it often, something inside me stirred with annoyance and, to be honest, anger. At the time I was still in the process of waking up to my identity and I didn’t quite understand why I felt that way. Today I see that this was because in their lumping me in with them, they wanted me to deny who I was, and this denial was an insult of the greatest kind.
It may say on my official documents that I am Canadian, but the mirror told me otherwise. When speaking with others I came to see that to be ‘Canadian’ was to accept ‘Canadian’ (i.e. White) values, history, and culture as one’s own—no matter one’s origin. That seemed to me to be disrespectful of those who came before me. And it reminded me of what I so hated about what I saw in mainstream Filipino culture.
And that brought me back to what it meant to be Filipino.
I looked at other cultures and I saw their pride in their history, in their traditions, in their language, and in their culture. What I saw in mine was a people proud of owning American goods, speaking with an ‘American’ accent, singing ‘American’ songs, and (if they’re lucky) having an ‘American’ spouse. I’ve heard other Asians mocking us for this, and it humiliated me because I agreed with them.
And that brings me back to that Filipino event, during that rainy day, next to Lake Ontario, and the smell of wet dog.
I looked around there and I saw men and women in so-called ‘traditional’ Filipino clothing.
I saw young Filipina ‘beauty’ pageant winners who seemed to have been chosen for their pale skin and closest approximation to a European ideal.
MCs proudly introduced a ‘traditional’ band that played ‘traditional’ Filipino songs, with ‘traditional’ instruments that were really Spanish.
On the main stage I heard American power ballads and watched a late middle aged woman, who in her introduction was supposed to introduce us to Filipino rock music, shake her hips in the ‘Elvis’ style and sing American 50s cover songs. Later a White singer headlined the Filipino event.
I saw brown people fawning over police officer guests (a group of Filipino officers and their white commander). It was the white officer that spoke to tell the audience that they needed more such events to prevent their youth from becoming criminals.
And I heard an individual from a remittance company claim that he was an ‘advocate’ for overseas Filipino workers because he allowed Filipinos to send money to disaster areas without charge (as if to be an advocate didn’t mean advocating for something).
But most of all that rainy evening, I saw a room of wet dogs playing up to their Canadian hosts. And despite the festive atmosphere (I mean who doesn’t love to watch cute dogs do cute tricks?) I kept hoping that the pets would remember their teeth and bite the hand of their master.
I see now that the shame of my youth was borne of an innate feeling that my culture was a defeated one. Defeated by the Spanish, then defeated again by the Americans—who then dug that dagger in deeper and causing more hurt than any normal war loss, by making my people love them.
My shame left me when I realized that this culture of defeat was only in the mainstream Filipino culture, the one put in place by the Americans, and supported by their lapdogs.
Underneath it all, and in the vast majority of the population of the islands, was a greater culture. There was a culture of defiance and pride. One that fought and won against the Spanish, fought—and continued (and continues) to fight despite the odds and great suffering—against the Americans, and one that beat back the Japanese.
Filipinos are not a defeated people. Defeat only occurs when one surrenders, my people are still fighting.
But when I go to these mainstream events, I am reminded of my shame. I am reminded that the ruling powers, and those that wish to ingratiate themselves to them, still embarrass me.
These people believe they have left behind in the shackles of slavery, but gladly carry leashes in their mouths.
Mainstream Filipinos take pride in their mimicry of Whites. They pride themselves in being able to sing their songs like them, tell stories that sound like theirs, wear clothes styled like theirs, and to be able to think like them. They do this to amuse them, and hopefully gain their favour. By making Master smile they hope to be given a treat for a reward.
This all was the source of my shame. Today it is a source of my anger.


28/08/2008 at 3:01 am
Nice reflections, Alex.
I, too, felt like that for a long time. And I still kind of envy the proud insular cultures of the rest of Asia. Sometimes it really bothers me that our culture is a half-bred mutt full of people trying to sire more half-breeds. But it was the quirks of history that made us who we are – dark brown people who eat too much meat, gamble like the Viets, philander like the Chinese, and pray like the Spaniards. We should take ownership of this history, and stop trying to be more American.
28/08/2008 at 3:19 am
Hi Alex,
I fully agree with the sentiments you have expressed in your post. But it’s time to elevate ourselves from anger to collective action – to shatter the root of our shame through the nobility of our ideas, and our solidarity with our people’s continuing struggle to be free from the vestiges of our colonial past.
28/08/2008 at 3:35 am
I agree J.C. It was just a bit of a bit of a relapse…I’m better now.
31/08/2008 at 3:11 pm
Wow,
That’s like a mirror of Indo events in oz, and how i feel about the indo culture. I also agree, action better than anger. Still, I love the way you expressed it.
06/10/2008 at 12:29 am
“We should take ownership of this history, and stop trying to be more American.”
I’m not Filipino but I agree wholeheartedly with that. More American is the LAST thing anybody should want to be.
17/12/2008 at 5:41 am
Alex, I cannot tell you how much relief I feel after reading this. Another (Aussie-born) Filipino that wants Philippines to snap out of it! The first step we should do is slap everyone that’s in denial. Philippines has so much potential as a nation and yet Filipinos worship talentless celebrities who have at least 3% Filipino blood. Our pride should be in what we can acheive as a nation rather than in the fame that one mestiza has acheived in a foreign country. It makes me so mad I’m even thinking of writing up a petition!! (Or maybe I should start a blog, vent and think of solutions in the meantime..?)
Thank you again, you’ve given another angry Filipino a lot of hope!
P.S. Monique, how do you feel about the Indo events in Oz? I had no idea you would have similar feelings..
10/05/2009 at 3:36 am
Filipino people should be proud of their culture and background. As an Italian-American, I have a lot of clients who are Filipino, and I think a lot of White Americans don’t understand them because of the cultural (and sometimes linguistic) barrier. I see a lot of good in Filipino culture. It’s a culture of respect, of honor, of dignity and seriousness. It respects its elders. It also respects learning. I researched, and found that for instance the requirements to become a lawyer in the Philippines are among the strictest and most academically rigorous in the world! Also, the Filipino culture is caring and nurturing. Medicine and the different healing arts are of paramount importance; that’s why so many Filipinos are involved in them. The Filipinos I have known are also perfectionists, even while they overcome hurdles like being new to the English language. As for copying other people’s cultures, what race or ethnicity around the world doesn’t do this? Look at how many White American kids listen to rap music and try to emulate rappers. I was just recently in Russia, and their reality and comedy TV shows now are complete clones of American shows. Looks like they’re throwing their own Russian culture in the garbage, at least on the TV shows for young people! Or videos posted by Chinese college students on YouTube, aping American boy bands… Pinoys, there is no reason to feel defeated or like mutts! The Filipino culture is strong, vibrant, interesting, and dignified.
14/05/2009 at 8:56 am
That’s an interesting article. I just wondered if you could tell me where to find more info on this topic ?
20/08/2009 at 10:41 am
There is no such thing as a defeated culture. By nature, culture adapts to anything that is introduced. say for example, the afghan culture that the taliban wants to keep is a mixture of persian, chinese,indian and Greek. The british, its influenced by spain, france and norway. America is the best example of a mixed culture heritage. Filipinos also have been influenced not just by americans, spaniards but by the chinese, the malays and the pacific islanders. I really don’t know why we always blame the americans and the spaniards. The chinese in hongkong never blamed the brits, the japs never blamed the americans, and the entire latin america never blamed spain and portugal. The US pride itself of its mixed culture. I think the anger and disgust are just products of our desire to belong to something that is pure and truly OURS because we filipinos here in america (continent) never felt the feeling of belonging. Unfortunately, there is no pure culture. it is evolving.